Persimmon Ridge Honey and Goat Farm
Contact
  • Beekeeping & Other Stuff
  • Home
  • About
  • The Goat Herder's Blog
  • Book Reviews!
  • Goats for Sale
  • Farm Update

Are Goats Really So Fragile?

8/15/2016

3 Comments

 
Picture
I have been keeping goats for 3 or 4 years now and in no way do I consider myself an expert. When I first started, I heard how difficult they were to keep and how they would not survive without special rations and regular drenching for worms. I wondered how on earth they had even evolved to the present day without our constant vigilance and intervention? 

Then I remembered attending my daughter's wedding in Jamaica. On the hour-and-a-half-long bus ride from the airport to the resort, I saw goats everywhere! Unattended, wild, grazing where they wished, and looking quite well. Since then, I've learned that a variety of places are home to goats that have "escaped" into the wild and have flourished--a lot of these places are desertlike! AND I've also learned that for 75% of the world, goat meat is their main source of animal protein. How fragile can they be?

Before getting goats, I attended a couple of seminars held by the local Ag agents. None of these agents had any firsthand experience with goats, but that didn't stop them from holding the seminars and advising us on best practices, nor did it stop them from issuing me a "Master Goat Producers" certificate before I'd ever even owned a goat or could really tell the difference between a goat and a sheep!

This made me doubt what I heard from the Ag experts. I quietly went about challenging their assumptions. (Quietly, cuz who wants the humiliation of being wrong about such heretical practices as letting goats be goats in all their goat-ness glory?) Since I brought home my first goats in 2011, I have never wormed them and have never fed them anything but hay in the dead of winter when the pasture is dormant. If anyone asked about my wacky negligence, I quoted An Pieschel, a renowned goat expert who advises these practices and also advises culling goats that cannot carry a normal parasite load. She says treating them just makes the parasites resistant and the goats weaker.  Amen, Sista!

My goats have a fenced "safe" pasture that they retire to at night (like chickens to roost), but they have daily access to the wider acreage of forest, pasture, brambles, and overgrowth. Without this, I doubt they would be so healthy. Twenty-three goats have been born on Persimmon Ridge in the past 3 or 4 years and I have lost only two goats to disease in this time. These were twin males that I'd weaned at 2 months--I'm guessing from Coccidiosis after the stress of such an early weaning. Now I band my males at 9 weeks and leave them with their mothers. Everybody is happier.

I am still learning from my goats. The first lesson that they have taught me is to be slow to intervene. When I try to "fix" things for them, I can more often than not make things much worse. The second thing is that the scientists who calculate goat rations are like the people who devised the food pyramid for humans--wrong! Like people, goats need what nature provides as a "whole food"--brambles, weeds, cedar bark, privet bushes, poison ivy and other vines, etc.

Last week I took a young buck to market because he was wrecking my fences and gates and trying to impregnate does before their time. He had never been wormed, had been raised only on pasture in spring, summer and fall--hay only last winter. He was graded as "choice." 


3 Comments
Pete Gummo
11/12/2018 04:22:17 pm

Glad to read your article as we are looking at raising goats along with our other animals . I thought that they where a hardy animal and your article agrees .

Reply
Jamie Charlson
3/11/2019 11:30:28 am

I'm new to goats, I got my first 2 from a dairy Farmer he had does that kidded early and allowed me to have 2 males. I bottle fed these 5 day old babies(they were feed cows milk from the store vitamin D, this is what was given to them when I got them) every day they were my joy. 10 weeks later one died through the night the next a week later... No symptoms just dead in the night...

I had these babies living in a large dog kennel from 5 days old to 8 weeks old at 7 weeks I took them to be banded, and I started weening them one less bottle a day .. they were going outside with me every time the weather permitting we have snow storms. They went outside more and more at the week goes on and I keep leasing milk and increasing hay and forage ... By almost 9 weeks input them outside with my chickens because they have a big coop and the goats for right in. I pick a day and out they go.. first night went great they seemed fine... Day 2b one of them died... 10 weeks old , so devastated I put up the kennel in the garage and spoil the remaining weather. He seems so happy and normal I watch daily everything seemed fine. Normal Stewart, but a week later he passed as well... What could I have done better.

Reply
Betty
3/11/2019 12:24:39 pm

Sorry to hear your tragic news, Jamie. Did either of the goats have scours (diarrhea) before their deaths? any sign of illness or decreased vitality? I think raising goats is most difficult when they cannot live as they were meant to live--raised by their mothers, part of a herd, hefted to a piece of land they know well and that produces the kind of food for them that they were designed to eat. Under these circumstances, goats can be hardy and "easy" to raise. But the more they must adapt to our environment, the more difficult it becomes and the more things can go wrong. It sounds like you did the best you could with what you had to work with. Again, I'm sorry to hear of this loss and know how difficult that can be.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Betty Taylor

    This blog chronicles the learning curve in goat farming.

    Archives

    August 2018
    August 2016
    July 2016
    December 2014
    October 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Baby Goats
    Goat Farming
    Hay Feeder
    Raising Goats

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.